TC

A reckoning is coming for emerging venture funds, and that, VCs say, is a good thing

Comment

U.S. Money falling from a partly cloud sky.
Image Credits: Kativ / Getty Images

Thousands of new venture capital funds have launched over the past few years, each hoping to carve out a long-term, lucrative place for themselves. PitchBook is tracking over 10,000 funds currently trying to raise money, and 45% of them are emerging fund managers, defined as a firm with less than three funds.

Those funds are duking it out for a mere 16% of the total capital that limited partner investors will spend on venture capital, according to PitchBook, down from about 23% for the decade that ended in 2019, before the pandemic-era VC frenzy years. 

More funds fighting for fewer dollars means a challenging landscape. We took the pulse of emerging fund managers about what it’s been like for them during these post-ZERP, venture-capital-winter years. For the most part, things seem to be shaking out quite nicely for emerging managers despite the economic headwinds. 

They admit that fundraising is tough, both for themselves and their founders, which means that in order to survive they are having to get creative. Some firms have had to cut their fund targets so they could close and start putting the funds to work. They’ve also had to get in with the big, multistage firms or risk losing out on deals.

“It’s really challenging how quickly things change within a market based on underwriting the type of founders we’re looking for and how the public markets look,” Marcos Fernandez, managing partner at Fiat Ventures, told TechCrunch. “If someone’s out there as a solo GP or even a couple of GPs without really anything too unique outside of being former operators, entrepreneurs, it’s really difficult to raise an emerging fund right now.”

A different kind of fundraising

When Joanna Drake, co-founder and managing partner at Magnify Ventures, went from being an entrepreneur to an investor, she had to learn that fundraising for a startup is wildly different than for a fund.

Joanna Drake, co-founder and managing partner at Magnify Ventures. Image Credits: Joanna Drake

“I found building the emerging fund one of the hardest things to do,” Drake said in an interview. “There’s so much complexity around getting a first- or second-time fund off the ground.”

As an entrepreneur, you have a short list of firms, you set your target date, take meetings and within a certain period of time know if you will be successful raising for your startup or not. As an emerging fund manager, “you can actually wander for years taking meetings without a lot of feedback,” she said.

Drake’s pedigree includes three successful venture-backed exits, and what she called “a very perfect resume” that included Berkeley and Stanford. Even so, the “long-winded and challenging process to raise capital” inspired Drake and Ben Black to create Raise Global, a community for emerging fund managers and the “forward-thinking LPs” as it calls them, who back them.

They launched Raise Global nearly a decade ago. Its goal was to help emerging managers meet LPs who wanted “to take a risk on the emerging manager category, but didn’t necessarily have the resources or the energy or time” to do the diligence on their own, she said.

A decade later, the Raise community includes hundreds of fund managers with assets under $200 million, and remains selective in its membership. Last year the org fielded 700 applicants, Drake said.

One exciting trend she’s seen through Raise is that the newest set of emerging managers are more geographically dispersed and more diverse than the classic Silicon Valley vest wearer. In addition, more emerging managers cracked the ceiling and were able to raise larger funds, some in the $100 million range, which used to be rare.

“The good news is we’ve been gathering data from both the LPs and the emerging managers for a decade now to show that there is a really exciting new set of managers coming through with a really different profile — geographically and diversity-wise — and LPs are really excited and continue to give back,” Drake said. 

Raise’s research among 660 emerging managers confirmed that 2023 was not the best year to raise new funds. Data showed that only 20% of emerging managers were raising $100 million, or more, funds. In 2022, that was 29%, and in 2021 it was 26%. About 27% of managers were targeting the $50 million to $99 million range, down from 29% in 2022 and 36% in 2021. 

Most of the action is taking place between zero and $49 million, where roughly 50% of emerging managers are raising, Drake said.

“That’s important because while there’s a handful of emerging managers that are able to raise larger than $100 million funds, it’s really a small percentage of the market,” Drake said. “So, they actually do not have the capital to take the companies to a later stage. They have to work with the larger firms and put together the syndicates. It’s actually one of the most important roles that they play.”

And, even if emerging fund managers successfully deploy their first funds and have good early results to show (although most funds take 10 years to return), that’s not enough to be secure.

Theresa Hajer, head of U.S. venture capital research at Cambridge Associates, agrees that there’s been an influx of emerging manager funds over the past seven years.

Cambridge is to VC funds what Michelin is to restaurants, helping to identify the best performers. But because of the odd winter period we’re in, past success isn’t actually a strong indicator on its own to access emerging managers, she warns. 

Newer managers who were investing during the 2019-2021 party days haven’t yet had the opportunity to build a track record in an environment that has had a valuation reset. So limited partners “need to sharpen their pencils and look very carefully because you can’t always rely on that performance,” she said.

Cambridge is carefully assessing younger fund managers with this in mind before giving them a stamp of approval. “This is a tough, tough environment,” she says. “But that’s the stance that we’ve taken for quite a long time, and other sophisticated limited partners in the market have done so as well.”

Secret to success

Hajer also says it’s important for emerging managers to play to their strengths. That can be from a deal flow perspective, connections with founders or developing relationships upstream with investors at larger firms.

Many new managers are doing this by specializing. They are targeting certain industries where general partners feel they have the expertise to give. Among Raise’s applicants in 2023, 70% had a thematic focus, Drake said. It’s also what she’s done for her own fund, Magnify.

“We’ve had some of the bigger firms, even at the Series A, reach back out and say, ‘We would like you to come in because you are the first investor in the care economy and in family tech. We need that domain expertise and want you on the table. We want the founders to have your support,’” Drake said. 

However, that’s not the case for emerging fund managers in emerging markets like Latin America. Monica Saggioro, co-founder and managing partner at MAYA Capital, told TechCrunch that because LatAm has not yet been swarmed with pre-seed and seed-stage funds, those that are tend to be generalists.

“As the market matures and competition increases, I believe there will be a stronger push for funds to specialize,” Saggioro said, but at this rate of investment in the region, she thinks that trend could be 10 or even 20 years out.

For Nick Moran, general partner at New Stack Ventures, the best thing about being an emerging manager is the ability to be nimble. He compared it to being a startup competing with an enterprise selling to a big customer. Huge enterprises are often slow and laden with legacy baggage infrastructure. On the other hand, the startup is more innovative and can make decisions faster, Moran said.

Nick Moran, general partner at New Stack Ventures.
Image Credits: New Stack Ventures

And while the venture capital world has the Accels and Sequoias of the world, and while they “are wonderful and do great work, they were built in a different era,” Moran said.

Rather, emerging venture firms have to be as innovative as the startups that they invest in, which means you’re no longer just dealing with capital, he said. They have to be unique, they have to have specialization, a unique thesis and insights that provide a value add for founders. Emerging managers also have to find the right partner at big firms that have a shared philosophy or sector, Moran said. 

In addition, smaller VCs have the ability to spend more time with founders, helping them grow from zero to one. For example, assisting with finding and recruiting talent and introductions with potential customers. Smaller funds are also experimenting with AI tools to tap into better investment strategies.

“Emerging managers have to compete on a different dimension,” Moran said. “You don’t want to be competing on the X and Y axis. You want to find a Z axis so unique that startups will jump to work with you and find room for you even when a Sequoia or an Accel or a Benchmark is involved.”

Other emerging funds are betting they can succeed by focusing as early as possible in a startup’s lifecycle. Magnify’s Drake said among the Raise firms she works with, 31% were working at the accelerator or pre-seed stages, while another 47% were working at the seed stage.

“That’s where the real early company-building work needs to happen,” Drake said. “Most of them are former operators, like myself, where we’ve had all functional areas report to us, so we can actually carefully work with the founding team to help them with the early talent, recruiting and development strategies. That stage is actually perfect for emerging managers to really roll up their sleeves.”

Relationships with bigger firms

Emerging managers work at the top of the deal-flow funnel. They help larger venture capital firms find promising companies, backing them before they’d earn a nod from larger check writers, Moran said. 

Nichole Wischoff, founder and general partner at Wischoff Ventures, told TechCrunch via email that “multistage funds are desperate for deal flow” and so they partner with any general partner they can to gain exposure to new deals. Those that successfully build such networks tend to thrive.

“This won’t change,” Wischoff said. “Similar to startups, the few emerging funds who continue to be able to get into great deals and eventually show exits will become blue chip firms themselves. Many decide to go multistage because it’s lucrative. Think Thrive Capital, Josh (Kushner) is really building something special here. The rest will fail.” 

Drew Glover, general partner at Fiat Ventures.
Image Credits: Fiat Ventures

Having a good network of multistage firms is one of the ways Brad Zions, founder and general partner at Pitbull Ventures, helps his portfolio companies.

“It’s about knowing the firms that like to invest in particular sectors and then knowing some of the partners who are the right people to champion a project or a potential investment in a startup,” Zions said in an interview. “I’ve developed a fairly extensive set of relationships with other emerging managers as well because I never lead rounds. I’m always able to squeeze into rounds that are just about to close.” 

Both Zions and Drew Glover, general partner at Fiat Ventures, said emerging fund managers are also helpful for larger VCs as it relates to diligence. Fiat Ventures shares education and market exposure on top of working with companies at their earliest stages, Glover said. 

As a result, the firm has a “very unique kind of macro and micro perspective on the entire world that a lot of VCs sit down and lean on us for,” he said. For instance, Fiat often has quarterly meetings with firms like Sequoia to discuss trends. 

“Anyone who’s not building relationships with some of the larger players is missing a huge opportunity,” Glover said. “These larger VCs are not going to take your call unless you have a really incredible track record with them that goes beyond just sending them a list of the top five businesses in your portfolio.”

A shake-out, then more success

Fiat Ventures’ Fernandez said that the VC winter has now lasted long enough that. “I do think that you’re gonna see a shake-out,” he said. 

All of these emerging funds are not going to make it. “That’s an unfortunate thing because there are some incredible emerging managers out there,” he said. Perhaps some will be absorbed by other funds, or some of the best investors will be hired on by other firms, he predicts.

But when the thinning happens, those emerging funds with “staying power” will grow stronger, with “less competition for a smaller number of deals that are out there.”

New Stack Ventures’ Moran added that this will make the emerging managers with increased specialization even more valuable to larger firms looking to write Series A-, B- and C-stage checks.

Meanwhile, MAYA Capital’s Saggioro is seeing that in Latin America as well. If interest rates drop in 2024, combined with the quality of founders she’s seeing, it won’t take for “the flywheel of a thriving ecosystem to speed up in the following years.”

More TechCrunch

Featured Article

Cloud infrastructure revenue approached $80 billion this quarter

The cloud infrastructure market has put the doldrums of 2023 firmly behind it with another big quarter. Revenue continues to grow at a brisk pace, fueled by interest in AI. Synergy Research reports revenue totaled $79 billion for the quarter, up $14.1 billion or 22% from last year. This marked…

Cloud infrastructure revenue approached $80 billion this quarter

The pharma giant won’t say how many patients were affected by its February data breach. A count by TechCrunch confirms that over a million people are affected.

Pharma giant Cencora is alerting millions about its data breach

Self-driving technology company Aurora Innovation is looking to raise hundreds of millions in additional capital as it races toward a driverless commercial launch by the end of 2024.  Aurora is…

Self-driving truck startup Aurora Innovation to sell up to $420M in shares ahead of commercial launch

Payments infrastructure firm Infibeam Avenues has acquired a majority 54% stake in Rediff.com for up to $3 million, a dramatic twist of fate for the 28-year-old business that was the…

Rediff, once an internet pioneer in India, sells majority stake for $3M

The ruling confirmed an earlier decision in April from the High Court of Podgorica which rejected a request to extradite the crypto fugitive to the United States.

Terraform Labs co-founder and crypto fugitive Do Kwon set for extradition to South Korea

A day after Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg talked about his newest social media experiment Threads reaching “almost” 200 million users on the company’s Q2 2024 earnings call, the platform has…

Meta’s Threads crosses 200 million active users

TechCrunch Disrupt 2024 will be in San Francisco on October 28–30, and we’re already excited! Disrupt brings innovation for every stage of your startup journey, and we could not bring you this…

Connect with Google Cloud, Aerospace, Qualcomm and more at Disrupt 2024

Featured Article

A comprehensive list of 2024 tech layoffs

The tech layoff wave is still going strong in 2024. Following significant workforce reductions in 2022 and 2023, this year has already seen 60,000 job cuts across 254 companies, according to independent layoffs tracker Layoffs.fyi. Companies like Tesla, Amazon, Google, TikTok, Snap and Microsoft have conducted sizable layoffs in the…

A comprehensive list of 2024 tech layoffs

Intel announced it would layoff more than 15% of its staff, or 15,000 employees, in a memo to employees on Thursday. The massive headcount is part of a large plan…

Intel to lay off 15,000 employees

Following the recent lawsuit filed by the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) against music generation startups Udio and Suno, Suno admitted in a court filing on Thursday that it did, in…

AI music startup Suno claims training model on copyrighted music is ‘fair use’

In spite of a drop for the quarter, iPhone remained Apple’s most important category by a wide margin.

iPad sales help bail out Apple amid a continued iPhone slide

Molly Alter wears a lot of hats. She’s a mocumentary filmmaker working on a project about an alternate reality where charades is big business. She’s a caesar salad connoisseur and…

How filming a cappella concerts and dance recitals led Northzone’s newest partner Molly Alter to a career in VC

Microsoft has a long and tangled history with OpenAI, having invested a reported $13 billion in the ChatGPT maker as part of a long-term partnership. As part of the deal,…

Microsoft now lists OpenAI as a competitor in AI and search

The San Jose-based startup raised $60 million in a round that values it lower than the $500 million valuation it garnered in its most recent round, according to multiple sources.

Sequoia-backed Knowde raises Series C at a valuation cut

X (formerly Twitter) can no longer be accessed in the Mac App Store, suggesting that it has been officially delisted.  Searches for both “Twitter” and “X” on Apple’s platform no…

Twitter disappears from Mac App Store

Google Thursday said that it is introducing new Gemini-powered features for Chrome’s desktop version, including Lens for desktop, tab compare for shopping assistance, and natural language integration for search history.…

Google brings Gemini-powered search history and Lens to Chrome desktop

When Xiaoyin Qu was growing up in China, she was obsessed with learning how to build paper airplanes that could do flips in the air. Her parents, though, didn’t have…

Heeyo built an AI chatbot to be a billion kids’ interactive tutor and friend

While the company was awarded a massive, $4.2 billion contract to accelerate Starliner development in 2014, it was structured as a “fixed-price” model.

Boeing bleeds another $125M on Starliner program, bringing total losses to $1.6B

Welcome back to TechCrunch Mobility — your central hub for news and insights on the future of transportation. Sign up here for free — just click TechCrunch Mobility! Summer road…

Anthony Levandowski bets on off-road autonomy, Nuro plots a comeback and Applied Intuition gets more investor love

Google’s new features include Gemini in BigQuery and Looker to help users with data engineering and analysis.

Google Cloud expands its database portfolio with new AI capabilities

Rad Power Bikes, the Seattle-based e-bike startup that has raised more than $300 million from investors, went through another round of layoffs in July, TechCrunch has exclusively learned. This is…

VC darling Rad Power Bikes hit with another round of layoffs

Five years ago, as robotaxis and self-driving truck startups were still raking in millions in venture capital, Anthony Levandowski turned to off-road autonomy. Now, that decision — which brought the…

Why Anthony Levandowski returned to his off-road autonomous vehicle roots with AV startup Pronto

Commercial space station company Vast is building a private microgravity research lab as part of its wider Haven-1 station plans. The module is set to launch no earlier than the…

Vast plans microgravity lab on its Haven-1 private space station

Google Cloud is giving Y Combinator startups access to a dedicated, subsidized cluster of Nvidia graphics processing units and Google tensor processing units to build AI models. It’s part of…

Google Cloud now has a dedicated cluster of Nvidia GPUs for Y Combinator startups

StackShare is one of the more popular platforms for developers to discuss, track, and share the tools they use to build applications.

Open source startup FOSSA is buying StackShare, a site used by 1.5M developers

Featured Article

Indian startups gut valuations ahead of IPO push

Ola Electric and FirstCry are set to test investor appetite with public listing, both pricing their shares below their previous valuation asks.

Indian startups gut valuations ahead of IPO push

The European Union’s risk-based regulation for applications of artificial intelligence has come into force starting from today.

The EU’s AI Act is now in force

The company also said it has received regulatory clearance to start Phase 2 clinical trials for a new drug in the U.S. later this year.

Healx, an AI-enabled drug discovery platform for rare diseases, raises $47M

The European Commission (EC) has given the go-ahead to HPE’s planned megabucks acquisition of Juniper Networks.

EU greenlights HPE’s $14B Juniper Networks acquisition

Meta, which develops one of the biggest foundational open source large language models, Llama, believes it will need significantly more computing power to train models in the future. Mark Zuckerberg…

Zuckerberg says Meta will need 10x more computing power to train Llama 4 than Llama 3